SIP vs STP vs SWP

Systematic Investment Plan (SIP), Systematic Transfer Plan (STP) and Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP) are all related to Mutual Funds and often confuse retail investors. While Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) is a mode of payment in mutual fund schemes and Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP) is just opposite of SIP, a mode of withdrawal/redeeming units from the funds. Systematic Transfer Plan (STP) is a mode of transfer of money from one mutual fund plan to the other in a systematic manner periodically.

Understanding SIP, STP & SWP

• What is a Systematic Investment Plan (SIP)?

An alternative to lump sum payment in mutual funds, SIP allows investors to invest the money in mutual funds through small installments monthly. This reduces the financial burden on the investor and gives the added benefits of power of compounding and rupee cost averaging. Each time you pay the installment amount, you buy more units of the fund. The fund money instead of one downpayment spreads over the time period of your investment tenure

• What is a Systematic Transfer Plan (STP)?

In this process, money from a fund is transferred to another mutual fund scheme but from the same Asset Management Company/AMC. This is not one time transfer of the whole amount but done through periodic payments of fixed amounts from time to time. It is similar to SIP as the investment in the fund scheme is being done through installments, but the difference is that the installment money is not withdrawn from the bank as in SIP but from the previous fund plan. This also averages out the costs like SIP as well as rebalances the portfolio through transfer and reallocation of the money from one asset to another like from Debt Funds to Equity or vice-versa

• What is a Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP)?

It is contrary to SIP where you withdraw the invested money from the fund plus the returns earned via short periodic withdrawals over the time. Each time you withdraw the money, you redeem certain units and gradually the number of units decline before it goes zero which means you have withdrawn the whole amount. You can also choose to withdraw only the returns earned per month instead of the invested amount which keeps it intact. These are the two types of SWPs, namely Fixed Income and Appreciation Withdrawal. Fixed Income is obtaining a fixed amount as income by redeeming certain units and Appreciation Withdrawal is receiving only the returns as per the varying ROI (Rate of Interest)

Advantages of SIP, STP and SWP

Comparison Among The Three – Systematic Investment Plan,  Systematic Transfer Plan and Systematic Withdrawal Plan

Parameters	SIP	STP	SWP
Kind of Plan	Investment	Transfer	Withdrawal
Process	Monthly Installment to one scheme	Monthly Transfer from one MF scheme to another	Periodic Withdrawals from a mutual fund scheme
Financial Goal	Long Term Capital Appreciation	Capital Appreciation for idle money	Source of regular income
Taxability	No tax on investments but capital gains	Taxation of every monthly transfer amount as it is redeemed from the previous mutual fund	Every withdrawal is taxed as its money/gains after redemption of units

Key Points of SIP, STP and SWP

• SIPs are usually for Equity Funds as these are highly volatile. Debt Funds are not so risky and hence SIPs have limited advantage for it
• STPs are generally done as a transfer from Debt to Equity Funds. It is done by the investors when they have a lump amount and they are fearful of market risks. An investor first invests in Debt Funds so that there is stability, security and higher returns than bank deposits. Then, s/he transfers it to Equity via STP aiming for higher capital appreciation
• Through STP, one can get consistent returns and take benefit of Equity Fund’s capital appreciation while still enjoying the security of Debt Funds
• The small periodic payments through STP is similar to SIP offering rupee averaging costs that also acts as a shield to volatile market as well as offers compounded growth with returns getting reinvested every month
• In SWP, periodic repayments can be monthly, quarterly, semi-annually or annually unlike SIPs or STPs where payments or transfers have to be monthly
• SWP is used as a payment mode usually when investors receive a lot of money from funds and seek a source of income from it. Many a times the returns received from one fund is deposited in some low risk MF scheme and money is withdrawn through SWP
• Regular withdrawals also help in avoiding market fluctuations as the entire amount is not redeemed in market highs or lows but throughout a certain time period that balances it. Regular withdrawals averages out return value
• Instead of redeeming the plan at once, and paying tax on the whole, SWP spans it over through multiple intervals that lowers the tax

Also Read: Taxation of Mutual Funds